Screwing our kids over
You ain't seen nothing yet.
The basic premise is pretty
easy. Like educate our children to be
good workers and citizens, and along the way have self-respect and happy
Families. This is a cultural problem, to
me, if we fail to do our adult responsibilities to our kids.
And if fairness, many places are
doing a good job at educating their children, and good on 'em for it.
But in the same vein, here's two written
practical consequences by Victor Davis Hansen:
The public schools were once the key to California’s
ascendance. Universal education turned out well-prepared citizens who were
responsible for California’s rosy future — one based on an excellent tripartite
higher education system of junior colleges, state colleges, and universities;
sophisticated dams and irrigation systems; and a network of modern freeways and
roads. In the private sphere, the culture of shame still prevailed, at least in
the sense that no one wanted his 16-year-old son identified in the papers (with
his home address no less) as arrested for breaking and entering. And such crime
was rare. Rural California was a checkerboard of 40- and 80-acre farms, with
families that were viable economic units and with children who worked until
dark after school. It is hard to steal when you must disc ten acres after
baseball practice.
I think it is a fair assessment to say that all of the above is long past. Since about 1992, on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) testing, California ranks between 41 and 48 in math and science, depending on the year and the particular grade that is assessed. About half of the incoming freshmen at the California State University system — the largest public university in the world — are not qualified to take college courses, and must first complete “remediation” to attain a level of competence that was assumed forty years ago in the senior year of high school. The students I taught at CSU Fresno were far better prepared in 1984 than those in 2004 were; the more money, administrators, “learning centers,” and counselors, the worse became the class work.
I finally threw out my old syllabi last month: the 1985 Greek Literature in Translation course at CSU Fresno seemed to read like a Harvard class in comparison to my 2003 version with half the reading, half the writing, and all sorts of directions on how to make up missed work and flunked exams. It wasn’t just that I lost my standards, but that I lost my students who could read.
I think it is a fair assessment to say that all of the above is long past. Since about 1992, on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) testing, California ranks between 41 and 48 in math and science, depending on the year and the particular grade that is assessed. About half of the incoming freshmen at the California State University system — the largest public university in the world — are not qualified to take college courses, and must first complete “remediation” to attain a level of competence that was assumed forty years ago in the senior year of high school. The students I taught at CSU Fresno were far better prepared in 1984 than those in 2004 were; the more money, administrators, “learning centers,” and counselors, the worse became the class work.
I finally threw out my old syllabi last month: the 1985 Greek Literature in Translation course at CSU Fresno seemed to read like a Harvard class in comparison to my 2003 version with half the reading, half the writing, and all sorts of directions on how to make up missed work and flunked exams. It wasn’t just that I lost my standards, but that I lost my students who could read.
Here's a second practical
example of what is coming, or may be here right now, depending on where you
live:
Does any of that matter? Well, yes. Those
who are not educated soon inherit the reins of public responsibility. In
practical terms, the symptoms are everywhere. I now expect that my county
property tax returns will have common errors, from the spelling of my name or
address to the particular acreage assessed.
When entering the bank, I expect people not just to not speak English, but occasionally not to write any language, and thus put a mark down, in Old West fashion, to cash their checks.
When I deal with a public agency, I assume the person on the opposite end of the counter or phone will not to be able to transact the requested service, or at least not be able to transact any other service other than the narrow one trained for. Calling any public agency is to receive a recording and then an incoherent order to press numerous buttons that lead to more recordings. Woe to the poor fool who walks into a Department of Motor Vehicles office on an average day, seeking to obtain a copy of his pink slip or find a registration form. The response is “get a number,” “make an appointment,” “get in line,” “wait,” or “see a supervisor.”
When entering the bank, I expect people not just to not speak English, but occasionally not to write any language, and thus put a mark down, in Old West fashion, to cash their checks.
When I deal with a public agency, I assume the person on the opposite end of the counter or phone will not to be able to transact the requested service, or at least not be able to transact any other service other than the narrow one trained for. Calling any public agency is to receive a recording and then an incoherent order to press numerous buttons that lead to more recordings. Woe to the poor fool who walks into a Department of Motor Vehicles office on an average day, seeking to obtain a copy of his pink slip or find a registration form. The response is “get a number,” “make an appointment,” “get in line,” “wait,” or “see a supervisor.”
Well, the obvious answer to me is to
vote for school board people who will advance our children for our common good,
as well as these children's future self-respect and happiness.
No comments:
Post a Comment