What Turkey Wants in the War
on ISIS
Why are we alone being asked to commit troops? Why
isn’t removing Assad part of the plan?
By Ibrahim Kalin in the Wall
Street Journal
Airstrikes alone will not be
sufficient to eliminate ISIS (also referred to as Islamic State). This has been
Turkey’s view from the outset of its march into Iraq and Syria, and military
officials in the U.S. and elsewhere now share this view. Yet as evidence mounts
that the air campaign is not enough, some seek to blame Turkey for not putting
boots on the ground.
Turkey is being asked to send
ground forces into Syria; to send arms to the Kurdish Democratic Union Party,
or PYD, in Kobani; and to allow the Kurdish Workers Party (PKK) fighters into
Syria. All three requests are based on faulty logic and a fundamental
misunderstanding of the facts on the ground.
No other member nation of
NATO or the U.S.-led international alliance has committed to sending ground
troops into Syria. President Obama and European allies including Germany and
Britain have explicitly ruled it out. Yet strangely enough, “ground troops”
have become Turkey’s—and only Turkey’s—obligation.
Turkey does support the fight
against ISIS and other terrorist threats. On Oct. 2 the nation’s parliament
passed a motion authorizing the government to use military force and to
cooperate with foreign troops against terrorist organizations in Syria and
Iraq. But criticizing Turkey for refusing to send ground troops when no other
country is committing troops to the fight defies any logic.
The idea that Turkey should
send arms to PYD—the Syrian branch of the outlawed PKK—is flawed. The PKK is
listed as a terrorist organization by the U.S., European Union and NATO, and
Turkey still faces the danger of PKK terrorism. Street clashes in Turkey’s
cities incited by PKK and its political wing (the Kurdish Peoples’ Democratic
Party) took the lives of 32 people over the last 10 days. Arming PKK’s Syrian
affiliate is tantamount to giving weapons to the PKK. Who will guarantee that
the weapons given to PYD will not end up in the hands of the PKK?
Turkey’s Daglica military
outpost, near the border of Iraq and Iran, recently came under heavy fire for
three days by the PKK. Turkey responded with an aerial attack on these forces
on Oct. 14. The government of Turkey will take every measure to protect its
citizens when their security is threatened. It would never arm outlawed
organizations that pose a threat to their safety. The PKK attack should be a
warning sign of the dangers that lie ahead if PKK or its affiliates receive
additional weapons. Despite these attacks, Turkey is committed to the peace
process to resolve the Kurdish issue.
Those proposing to let PKK
fighters enter Syria to fight alongside PYD forces against ISIS ignore the
duplicitous alliances among the factions inside Syria. It is well-established
that the PYD has largely allied itself with the regime of Bashar Assad, and
moved to control Kurdish-populated areas. PYD has never joined other Syrian
opposition groups such as the Free Syrian Army in opposing the Assad regime.
Turkey has already done more
than any other country for the victims of Assad’s repression. It is hosting
over 1.6 million Syrian refugees in its territory. It has spent more than $4
billion for humanitarian relief without significant international support. And
Turkey prevented a human tragedy by virtually evacuating Kobani when it
accepted close to 200,000 Kurds fleeing ISIS. Carol Batchelor, of the Office of
the U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees, was recently quoted as saying that
when it comes to saving lives, “The U.N. could not catch up with Turkey.”
Turkey will work with the
U.S. and other allies to train and equip Syrian moderate opposition groups to
fight against ISIS and the Assad regime—a regime that is responsible for the
killing of more than 200,000 people in the last three and a half years. ISIS’s
barbaric beheadings and summary executions, horrible and disgusting as they
are, should not shadow the war crimes and crimes against humanity perpetrated
by Mr. Assad.
Peace, security and stability
in Syria cannot be established with the Assad regime remaining in power. In
addition, Mr. Assad’s bloody war bears responsibility for the barbaric acts of
ISIS as it prepared the ground for such terrorist groups to emerge and grow in
the first place. Hitting ISIS while ignoring the Assad regime alone is a
shortsighted strategy that will not end the bloodshed in Syria and Iraq.
Mr. Kalin is deputy secretary general of the
presidency of the Republic of Turkey.
No comments:
Post a Comment