Rural Cambodia, Though Far Off the Grid, Is Finding Its Way Online

Rural Cambodia, Though Far Off the Grid, Is Finding Its Way Online

By James Brooke in the New York Times

Published: January 26, 2004

OSIENGLE, Cambodia - In this village on the edge of a primordial forest, where the occasional oxcart creaks down the red earth main street, townspeople were debating one recent afternoon what to say in their first e-mail transmission.

"I think we should send a message to the governor, asking for land titles," said Kim Seng, 53, who owns a mud-floor restaurant, as his wife listened from a hammock. Conjuring up the power and prestige of a letter sent by computer, he added confidently, "The governor will pay attention to our issues."

Without wires for electricity or telephones, this village of about 800 people has nevertheless joined the online world, taking part in a development project set up by an American benefactor to connect 13 rural schools to the Internet.

Since the system went into place last September at the new elementary school here in Cambodia's remote northeast corner, solar panels have been powering three computers. Once a day, an Internet "Motoman" rides a cherry red Honda motorcycle slowly past the school. On the passenger seat is a gray metal box with a short fat antenna. The box holds a wireless Wi-Fi chip set that allows the exchange of e-mail between the box and computers. Briefly, this schoolyard of tree stumps and a hand-cranked water well becomes an Internet hot spot.

It is a digital pony express: five Motomen ride their routes five days a week, downloading and uploading e-mail. The system, developed by a Boston company, First Mile Solutions, uses a receiver box powered by the motorcycle's battery. The driver need only roll slowly past the school to download all the village's outgoing e-mail and deliver incoming e-mail. The school's computer system and antenna are powered by solar panels. Newly collected data is stored for the day in a computer strapped to the back of the motorcycle. At dusk, the motorcycles converge on the provincial capital, Ban Lung, where an advanced school is equipped with a satellite dish, allowing a bulk e-mail exchange with the outside world.

The Motoman program is sponsored by American Assistance for Cambodia, a group based in Phnom Penh and run by Bernard Krisher, the Far East representative of the Media Laboratory of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The Media Lab gives technical advice to the Motoman program, which offers third world schools a way to cut costs by sharing one dish and one uplink fee.

To some, the Motoman system is a cumbersome compromise, made necessary by a government that makes money through monopolies that inflate the prices of satellite dishes and uplink fees far beyond the means of villages like this one, where individual incomes average $1 a day.

"The 50 poorest countries in the world get more money from telephone access fees than anything else," said Nicholas Negroponte, a founding director of the Media Lab. An advocate of an Internet bridge to rural Asia, Mr. Negroponte spoke outside a computer-equipped, online school he and his wife, Elaine, pay for 120 miles west of here. Almost as he spoke - in early January - police were raiding Internet cafes in Phnom Penh, confiscating equipment for making Internet telephone calls. The cafes charged as little as 5 cents a minute to call the United States, far below the government-mandated minimum of 96 cents for phone calls using conventional technology.

In Phnom Penh, dozens of Internet cafes offer access for 50 cents an hour, and 20 stores sell used computers imported from Japan. About 1,000 Netizens a day log on to the Web site of King Norodom Sihanouk, www.norodomsihanouk.info. A used desktop computer can be bought for about $30 - the monthly wage for a schoolteacher - while used laptops can be had for as little as $50.

About 75 percent of Cambodia's 13 million people, though, live in rural areas, and smooth roads and utility lines usually stop at the edge of the provincial capital. The village of O Siengle, a collection of wooden houses on stilts, is emblematic of life for the millions of Asians who live on the unwired side of the digital divide.

From this village to Ban Lung, the capital of Ratanakiri Province, is only 18 miles. But even in the dry season, it is a jolting two-hour ride in a sturdy Russian-made jeep.

Users say the Motoman system is starting to change lives.

"It helps us with our diagnoses,'' Chanmarith Ly, deputy director of the provincial hospital in Ban Lung, said of the telemedicine project that allows him to send photographs of patients, X-rays, ultrasounds and electrocardiograms to specialists in Boston at Partners Telemedicine, a program of the Partners HealthCare System. Doctors from the staff of Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School review the files and send diagnoses, all pro bono.

Joseph C. Kvedar, a Partners doctor who directs the Boston end of the telemedicine project, saw the value of the effort when he visited the eight doctors at the Ban Lung hospital in November.

"The Cambodian doctors know how to do malaria, tuberculosis, chronic tropical infection conditions like diarrhea, dengue fever," he said by telephone from Boston. "But diabetes, hypertension, the diseases of the modern world, are just not in their lexicon. It is a perfect fit."

Still, once-a-day e-mail service has its drawbacks. A few steps from Dr. Ly's hospital office, Kuy Sothy, a 21-year-old teacher, lay on a hospital bed, recovering from a severe bout of malaria.

"I sent the e-mail to the hospital," she said, resting on a woven rattan mat.

Bunthan Hun, the project's local technology director, interjected, "We got the e-mail, but you got here first." Indeed, the same motorcycle that carried Miss Sothy to the hospital carried the Wi-Fi box with her e-mail message.

The Americans behind the project hope that e-mail will also bring economic benefits by connecting rural people and their products to wider markets.

In Rovieng, where Mr. Negroponte finances his school, women weavers sell their raw silk scarves and ties through www.villageleap.com, a Web site operated by Mr. Krisher's group. Once marginalized, these traditional weavers now have among the town's highest incomes. Here in Ratanakiri, a land-locked province bordering southern Laos and the central highlands of Vietnam, Mr. Krisher hopes to market local products eventually through an informational Web site he maintains, www.ratanakiri.com.

For the younger generation, the new school computers are like magnets. While the shelf of donated books gathered dust, the computers gathered knots of students, dressed in blue and white uniforms.

"I very much want to go to high school, but I don't know if I can because we are poor," said Chenda Prom, 15 years old. Studying the keyboard, she added, "I want to learn computers for my future."

Poster’s comments:

1)       A system like this article discusses could also exist in a time of Rolling Blackouts in the new world USA, also. After all, people want to communicate with each other, often need to for business reasons, and sometimes just because.  And most of us now depend on electricity as a best way to get the energy we want to have where we live and work. And keep in mind there are other ways to get energy, like from falling water, using coal, or even having to use a mule and pulled wagon, including making sure the animals are fed and watered in a timely manner.

2)      Solar electric plants are not a “be all, end all”. I have one and am still learning how to best use it in this less than ideal solar plant area in east Tennessee, in 2015. For example one has to clean the solar panels several times a year to maximize solar input. And battery banks have shelf lives, and can I get new ones with connecting cables in 2021, for another example. How I choose to set it all up provides another example.

3)      Right now I use it for recharging my many rechargeable batteries routinely, and to run my once a month haircut service using electric shears (with a sine wave inverter), mostly for the males. Females tend to like a more scissors and water spray and mirror oriented method. I can do that, too. For the females, it is probably advantageous that I find someone who can do it better than me. After all, my hair trimmings are probably more Marine-like than most females want to endure.

4)      Now there is hope, It is called improvising and using our brains, educations, and experiences. This idea almost sounds religious, too. And this approach uses faith vice certainty about the future.

5)      Most situations, histories, available materials, etc. will vary enough to where no one solution will work best for all. Hence the above article is just one way to get things to work better during hard times, with an expectation for a better future for our children, too. The same idea could apply to the various religions and their offshoots, too.

6)      Before the Internet there was still email. It used a system of “nodes” that moved emails along, albeit slower than the more instantaneous  emails (which still use nodes of a kind) we have today (but still faster than “snail mail”, the postal system many countries presently have and could go back to).

7)      Genealogy (often Family history research) was a big user of this old system. It probably uses the newer email system, too, but I don’t know for sure. Emails back then were said to “bounce” around,  for even another example. And even then we had “agents”, software programs if you will, that scoured thousands of emails for surnames we wanted to follow up on. That method alone could reduce 1,500 emails to like 30 emails, for even another example.